An Emerging Hispanic Voice Defends Her âMaidsâ
LOS ANGELES â" At a premiere party at the Spanish-colonial-style Bel-Air Bay Club last week for the new Lifetime show âDevious Maids,â the center of attention was not the five actresses who play the lead characters, Latina maids who cook, clean and scheme while looking after wealthy white families in Beverly Hills.

The Mexican-American actress Eva Longoria is becoming a public figure.

âDesperate Housewives,â with from left, Felicity Huffman, Ms. Longoria, Teri Hatcher and Marcia Cross in 2004.
Instead, the spotlight fell on one of the executive producers, Eva Longoria, better known for her own role as the wealthy Gabrielle Solis on âDesperate Housewives.â She worked the room like a politician, making grand introductions punctuated by a bright smile and a hug and a kiss on the cheek, and holding barely audible conversations.
Her biggest priority was to check in on each of âthe girlsâ â" as she called the five actresses â" to see how they had fared on the red carpet. Nine years ago Ms. Longoria was a young, relatively unknown actress in the cast of âDesperate Housewives.â But then she changed the script, positioning herself as a Hollywood power player on Latino issues and a highly regarded political advocate.
Now she finds herself in a position of having to defend her latest project against critics who say the show relies too much on the cliché of the Hispanic maid.
âWhen people talk about stereotypical maids, these maids are anything but,â Ms. Longoria, 38, said over a long lunch at the Chateau Marmont in West Hollywood two days before the premiere party. She said future plot points would reveal more developed people.
She was eager to counter the negative reactions to the show. âI think itâs important for us to have a dialogue of identity in our culture, and even though this show may not be your experience, it is a lot of peopleâs experience,â she said. Latinos, she added, âover-index in domestic workers: that is a fact, thatâs not an opinion.â
The ratings for the premiere of âDevious Maids,â at 10 on Sunday night, were modest. Going up against the season finale of AMCâs âMad Men,â the show attracted 2 million viewers, slightly below the Lifetime show that preceded it at 9, âDrop Dead Divaâ (2.2 million).
Ms. Longoriaâs rise as a media force has been paralleled by her political ascent. She stumped for President Obama in 2012, helping round up critical Hispanic voters, and she was a founder of the Futuro Fund, which raised $32 million for the campaign. She recently spoke at the Clinton Global Initiative in Chicago; left a few days later for Colombia to film a documentary for the Half the Sky Movement, an international womenâs advocacy group; and signed on to a fund-raising drive for the political group Battleground Texas, whose goal is to raise money to âput Democrats back on the mapâ in the state, in the words of her message on the groupâs home page.
And in May she completed a masterâs degree in Chicano studies from California State University, Northridge.
âIâm a little in awe in terms of how sheâs transformed herself,â said Marc Cherry, an executive producer of both âDevious Maidsâ and âDesperate Housewives,â who cast Ms. Longoria in 2004. âShe was just an actress that had done a couple of prime-time shows and had done some daytime.â
Before its debut, the criticism of âDevious Maidsâ included an open letter in The Huffington Post from Michelle Herrera Mulligan, the editor in chief of Cosmopolitan for Latinas, who called the show a âwasted opportunity.â (Ms. Longoria had been on the magazineâs spring cover months before Ms. Mulliganâs letter was published online.)
Alisa Lynn Valdes, a former journalist and author of the novel âThe Dirty Girls Social Club,â wrote a critical online opinion piece on NBCLatino.com about the show. âIt is not wrong to be a maid, or even a Latina maid,â she wrote, âbut there is something very wrong with an American entertainment industry that continually tells Latinas that this is all they are or can ever be.â
Most maids, however, donât sleep with their bosses. The showâs first episode begins with a whopping, albeit campy, dose of classism, with an employer threatening to deport her maid for having sex with the employerâs husband.
âThey are five strong, female, Latina characters, so itâs like the three hurdles we had to overcome to get this on the air in Hollywood,â said Ms. Longoria, who added that the show also has two Latina writers out of five. âYouâre never the lead, then if you are the lead, you are usually a lead that services the main character, which is a white male actor.â
Ms. Longoria grew up far from Beverly Hills, in Corpus Christi, Tex., a daughter of Mexican-American parents. Her mother was a special-education teacher, and her father was a tool engineer in the Army. âI took out loans to pay for school,â Ms. Longoria told the Democratic National Convention in 2012 during a speech that made much of her working-class roots. âThen I changed oil in a mechanic shop, flipped burgers at Wendyâs, taught aerobics and worked on campus to pay them back.â
