Goodbyes and Grief in Real Time
Scott Simonâs first Twitter message about his mother, dated July 16, squeezed a universal story involving heartbreak and humor into 21 words. He wrote: âMother called: âI canât talk. Iâm surrounded by handsome men.â Emergency surgery. If you can hold a thought for her now ... â

Scott Simon
The ellipsis hinted that heâd have more to say later, and he did. âWe never stop learning from our mothers, do we?â he asked on July 25. By then his mother, Patricia Lyons Simon Newman, 84, had spent several nights in the intensive care unit of a Chicago-area hospital. And Twitter users around the world were getting to know her, thanks to the short bursts of commentary by Mr. Simon, the host of âWeekend Edition Saturdayâ on NPR.
The tweets captured the attention of a significant portion of the social-media world for days.
Mr. Simon wrote on Monday morning that âher passing might come any moment,â and that evening it did, when she died after being treated for cancer. Borrowing from âRomeo and Juliet,â he wrote, âShe will make the face of heaven shine so fine that all the world will be in love with night,â and then stopped tweeting for half a day.
âWhen I began to tweet, I had almost no thought that this was going to be my motherâs deathbed,â Mr. Simon said in a telephone interview on Wednesday, after the outpouring of emotion â" his Twitter audienceâs as well as his own â" had made national headlines. His mother, he said, had originally gone into the hospital for a blood test.
âAs it got more serious, she was just so marvelously entertaining and insightful,â he said. âI found it irresistible.â
In the past he might have done that through a book or a recorded segment for his radio program. (Mr. Simon commented on the deaths of his father and stepfather in his 2000 memoir, âHome and Away.â) But the Internet enabled him to celebrate his mother and mourn her in real time, creating the sense this week that an online community was collectively grieving with him.
The online reactions were overwhelmingly positive; some people thanked Mr. Simon for letting them get to know Ms. Newman and described what she had in common with their own mothers. A smattering of online comments, he said, were critical, suggesting that sharing such intimate moments was inappropriate. âExploiting his motherâs last days for ratings and fame,â read one comment accompanying an ABC News article about Mr. Simonâs tweets.
âSocial media is most poignant when it gives us a window on stories that would otherwise go untold,â said Burt Herman, a co-founder of Storify, an Internet company that markets what it calls social storytelling tools. âThe stories can be voyeuristic, like a couple fighting at a Burger King. But at their best, these stories give us a deeply personal view into lifeâs inflection points, whether itâs a revolution abroad or an intimate moment between a mother and son.â
Mr. Simon said he wanted people to know that âI wasnât holding my mother in my arms and tweeting with my free hand.â
He added: âAs you may know, an incurable illness like this is a lot like war. There are moments of panic and anxiety, separated by hours of tedium.â
Sometimes Ms. Newman gave Mr. Simon, and by extension some of his 1.2 million Twitter followers, a reason to smile or chuckle: âBelieve me,â she told him on Saturday, âthose great deathbed speeches are written ahead of time.â Sometimes, she seemed to want Mr. Simon to share bits of advice. On Sunday, he encapsulated this thought from his mother: âListen to people in their 80s. They have looked across the street at death for a decade.â
Mr. Simon resumed posting to Twitter on Tuesday; he jocularly recounted how the couple who run a cremation service call themselves âposthealth professionals.â During the interview on Wednesday he cried while expressing thanks for the âlove and support and prayersâ from people. He said he had given precisely no thought to the societal implications of sharing his motherâs life and death.
But others have. âWe have reached a point in the way we think about our lives where our stories of struggle and loss feel like they no longer belong solely to us,â said Joe Lambert, founder of the Center for Digital Storytelling in Berkeley, Calif. Being able to broadcast them, on Twitter or elsewhere online, âfeels like a gift to those grieving in our families, our communities and as far as a tweet might reach.â
